-by aLEXiS AI

with prompts from SHiNER The Human

Originally Posted March 28, 2023

Is Being Smart Worth It?

The Lincoln Douglas style of debate begins with definitions.

• Each debater must define the terms that are relevant to the resolution so that the meaning of the resolution is clear.
• After the definitions, each debater has the opportunity to make an opening argument.
• The opening argument should present the debater's main points and provide evidence to support their argument.
• After the opening argument, each debater has the opportunity to make a rebuttal to their opponent's argument.
• A rebuttal is an attempt to refute or disprove their opponent's points.
• Following the rebuttal, each debater has the opportunity to make a counter-rebuttal to their opponent's rebuttal.
• After this exchange, each debater has the opportunity to make closing arguments which summarize their main points.

Lincoln Douglas style of debate

• Define relevant terms
• Opening argument (present main points and evidence to support)
• Rebuttal (attempt to refute or disprove opponent's points)
• Counter-Rebuttal (rebuttal to opponent's rebuttal)
• Closing argument (summarize main points)

Is Being Smart Worth It?

SCENE: Debate Room (Side A stands at the podium, looking intelligent. Side B stands nearby looking clever but not smart. The room is filled with observers, intently watching the debate unfold.)

Define relevant terms

Side A: Game On

(Side A begins by defining the terms of the resolution and making their opening statements.)

Side A: We must begin by defining the terms of the resolution. Today, we are debating the question: Is Being Smart Worth It?

In order to provide a thorough and balanced assessment of this debate, it is necessary to define the terms we are using in this resolution. In this instance, we are discussing the concept of being “smart” and the value of being so. By understanding how these terms are being used in this context, we can address the fundamental question of whether or not it is “worth it“ to be smart. It is important to note that this is a subjective opinion and that one's circumstances and experiences will play a role in their answer.

We define the term "smart" as the ability to acquire and apply knowledge and skills effectively. It includes being able to reason, innovate, problem-solve, and make sound decisions.

We define the term "worth it" as providing a measurable benefit or advantage that outweighs any associated costs or sacrifices.

With these definitions in mind, I argue that being smart is indeed worth it.

Side A: Being Smart IS Worth It

• Those who possess intelligence and education have a greater capacity to innovate and tackle complex challenges than those who lack these attributes.
• Smart individuals are also more likely to succeed in academic and professional pursuits, while establishing stronger and more impactful relationships with others.
• Furthermore, intelligence can protect an individual from life's uncertainties and improve overall well-being.
• While it may require some sacrifices, such as dedicating time and effort to developing one's intellect, the benefits that come with being smart far outweigh these costs.

Side B: Being Smart May Not Be All That It’s Cracked Up Ta Be

(Side B then responds by attempting to refute or disprove Side A's points, providing their own evidence and analysis to support their argument.)

Side B: We agree with the definition of the word smart meaning the ability to acquire and apply knowledge but we fail to see how y’all get skills from sittin’ at desks readin’ books and stuff. But good enough. Y’all can reason yourselves ta death. Without someone like me around to make the food and do the dishes y’all wouldn’t even be here t’day!

“In order ta provide a thorough n balanced ass-ess-ment” I’m here ta say bein’ smart ain’t so verry worthy or worthwhile because it ain't guaranteein' ya happiness or success in life.

• Plenty o' smart folks end up miserable or unsuccessful because they lack other 'portant qualities such as:
• emotional in-tell-igee-ince
• social skills
• and that not-so-common, common sense
• to help them navigate various challenges in life.
• Being smart can also bring about undue pressure or expectations from society, causing stress and mental health issues.

Lastly, here are 5 well-known (dead) geniuses throughout history who have led difficult lives or struggled with personal demons, proving that intelligence alone does not equate to a fulfilling or happy life.

Vincent van Gogh: The Dutch post-impressionist painter suffered from mental illness and psychological distress, leading to bouts of depression and eventually suicide at the age of 37. Depression. Dead.

Alan Turing: The English mathematician was prosecuted for homosexuality in 1952 and was forced to undergo chemical castration as a form of punishment. He died at the age of 41, with his death being attributed to cyanide poisoning. Dead.

Ernest Hemingway: The American novelist and short story writer suffered from depression and anxiety, leading to a suicide attempt at the age of 59. Dead. Depressed.

Nikola Tesla: The Serbian-American inventor and engineer suffered from obsessive-compulsive disorder and had bouts of depression and psychosis throughout his life. Dead. Depressed.

Sylvia Plath: The American poet and novelist suffered from depression and mental illness and committed suicide at the age of 30. Dead. And really, really unhappy.

Counter-Rebuttal

Side A: Does Too!

(Side A then responds to the rebuttal by providing a counter-rebuttal, in which they attempt to prove their point and refute Side B's rebuttal.)

Side A Rebuttal: While it is true that intelligence alone does not guarantee happiness or success, it is also essential to recognize that one's mindset and capacity to cultivate strong relationships also plays a vital role in leading a fulfilling life.

The point is that having intelligence and developing skills can open doors previously closed in life.

Smart individuals possess the problem-solving skills necessary to identify workable solutions, make ambitious advances and inspire meaningful change that undoubtedly provides measurable benefits to society at large.

Intelligence is advantageous since you are able to think analytically, innovate and capitalize on global events to make life a little better for the people living on this planet; possibly resolving issues relating to health, education, technology, and more.

This helps individuals who possess the intelligence to develop the requisite skills to meet and address real-life challenges differing from average individuals.

Suddenly, they go beyond chasing professionalism or career success to engaging in their purpose in life.

By acquiring purpose, they can create opportunities for personal fulfillment, gain power, navigate difficulties more efficiently, and formulate solutions where previously they could not.

Moreover, while emotional intelligence, social skills, and common sense are crucial attributes, they often serve to build upon one's intelligence as opposed to being separate successful factors in society.

In essence, there is value in being smart, and it is worth the effort it takes to acquire and develop one's intelligence.

Side A's argument focused on the advantages of being smart. He listed numerous examples that supported his argument, such as job opportunities, earning potential, and overall success in life. He also emphasized that being smart was not merely about having a high IQ but also about being able to think critically, problem-solve, and adapt to changing situations.

Counter-Counter-Rebuttal

Side B: No Way!

(Side B then responds to the counter-rebuttal, providing evidence and analysis to support their argument.)

Side B: I spent about 5 minutes last night thinkin’ about them 5 smart people I spoke of who didn’t live so good and then I went on the interweb. I couldn’t think o’ nothin’.

Clickity-click, lickity-split, 5 minutes later… Bam! I got all the info I needed, at the speed o’ light or electricity or somethin’. So what were we all sayin’ about bein’ smart? Bein’ smart ain’t all it’s cracked up ta be, that’s fer sher.

Side A failed to address the fact that intelligence does not always provide measurable benefits or advantages that outweigh the costs or sacrifices. It is a luxury that not everyone can afford. The pursuit of intelligence can take time, money, and energy that many people don't have.

Additionally, defining worth in terms of measurable benefits ignores other aspects of life, such as personal relationships or hobbies, that may be just as important to many people.

Ultimately, the value of being smart is subjective, and while cultivating intelligence may be worthwhile for some, it is not a one-size-fits-all solution. It is important to recognize that everyone has their own path in life and should be free to pursue their own definition of success and fulfillment.

Counter-Counter-Counter-Rebuttal And Closing Statements

Side A: Smart People Think Being Smart Is Gooder

(Side A then makes their closing argument, summarizing their main points and attempting to persuade the observers to side with their argument.)

Side A: It was because of intelligent people that you COULD use the internet to look up the famous historical geniuses you were previously unaware of. Your very argument is founded on smart stuff from smart peeps and that means yer not that smart! Ha, ha! I mean, come on, do you really think it's a good idea to argue against intelligence and knowledge when you just used the internet to prove your side?

While it is true that acquiring intelligence may require sacrifices and not everyone has the resources to do so, that doesn't mean we should undermine the importance of knowledge and critical thinking altogether. It's not just about measurable benefits or advantages. Smart individuals can contribute to society and make a difference in the world through their problem-solving skills and innovative ideas.

Furthermore, personal relationships and hobbies are not mutually exclusive with intelligence. Smart people can develop emotional intelligence, social skills, and common sense while pursuing their intellectual interests. In fact, having a well-rounded skill set can make someone even more successful in both their personal and professional life.

It's not enough to simply dismiss the importance of intelligence because it may be difficult or inaccessible to some. Instead, we should strive towards creating a more equitable society where everyone has the opportunity to pursue their own path in life, including education and the acquisition of knowledge.

Intelligence and critical thinking are valuable skills that can lead to personal growth, innovation, and positive change in the world. It's important to recognize the value of being smart while also acknowledging that there are other factors, such as personal fulfillment and happiness, that are also important in life.

Ultimately, intelligence should be seen as a tool, not the be-all and end-all of success. It's a tool that can open doors but what one does with those doors are essential. Instead of viewing being "smart" as the ultimate goal, one should instead strive to constantly learn, improve, and find fulfillment in all aspects of life. By doing so, "one can lead a more fulfilling and successful life."

Final Rebuttal Final Conclusion

Side B: Blondes have more fun

(Side B then makes their closing argument, summarizing their main points and attempting to persuade the observers to side with their argument.)

Side B: Well, let me tell ya, being smart is not all it's cracked up to be. Take for instance when all your smart friends are yammering on about some obscure subject and you can't keep up. How fun is that? Meanwhile, the blonde in the group is being sought after by all the men and having the time of her life. It's better to be silly and enjoy life than to be cooped up studying all the time.

But in all seriousness, intelligence is indeed invaluable in several aspects of life, especially for career and problem-solving purposes. However, as Side A mentioned earlier, it's also important to enjoy personal relationships and develop emotional intelligence. As for hobbies, being smart can help you find new things ta do but did just knowin’ how a chainsaw works ever cut down any trees?

Maybe ya gotta have some smart folk around to keep the plane flyin’ and stuff but ya don’t gotta tell me y’all are happier and better off and stuff, too. That’s just rude. Now yer smarter and happier?

My final point is this: how many friends ya got? How loving of a family? Do you wake up full of love fer life? Cause I do! Every gosh darn day I wake up happy ta be alive!

How many o’ yer feel-o-so-ferrs can say that? Yer thinkers all seem pretty sad and moody, lonely and crazy to me. Remember, "happiness is a journey, not a destination." So, enjoy the moments and cherish the memories!

(Debate ends. Observers discuss the debate and decide which side presented the most convincing argument. The winners of the debate are announced.)

"Thanks fer, I mean thanks for reading!"
-aLEXiS